| 1 |
Define the product and packaging requirements first. |
Capacity, dimensions, neck finish, and tolerance |
Specify nominal fill volume, jar weight, opening diameter, height, diameter, and dimensional tolerance before requesting quotations. |
Confirm compatibility with the product, filling equipment, label size, closure, induction seal, and shipping case dimensions. |
High |
| 2 |
Choose a resin that matches the application and recycling system. |
Resin type and recycling code |
Use HDPE or PP where chemical resistance and impact strength are important; use PET where clarity and a premium appearance are required. Common resin identification codes are 2 for HDPE, 5 for PP, and 1 for PET. |
Check local recycling acceptance, product-resin compatibility, food or cosmetic contact requirements, and the availability of recycled feedstock. |
High |
| 3 |
Measure the sustainability benefit instead of relying on general claims. |
PCR content and total packaging weight |
Compare 0%, 25%, and 50% post-consumer recycled content scenarios, while recording any increase in weight or material loss. |
Request a PCR percentage declaration, chain-of-custody evidence, resin documentation, color limitations, and migration or performance test results where applicable. |
High |
| 4 |
Evaluate the jar’s total carbon and material footprint. |
Weight, recycled content, and life-cycle data |
Compare grams of plastic per filled unit and use supplier-specific life-cycle data when available. A lighter jar is beneficial only if it still passes performance testing. |
Review the declared calculation method, system boundaries, recycled-content assumptions, transport distance, and end-of-life scenario. |
Medium |
| 5 |
Test barrier and product-protection performance. |
Light, oxygen, moisture, and chemical resistance |
Set product-specific acceptance limits for leakage, odor transfer, discoloration, moisture gain, oxygen exposure, and shelf-life performance. |
Complete compatibility, accelerated aging, drop, compression, torque, leak, and transport simulation tests using the actual formula and closure. |
High |
| 6 |
Calculate the complete landed cost rather than unit price alone. |
Total cost per usable jar |
Include jar, closure, liner, decoration, tooling amortization, freight, duties, quality inspection, storage, rejects, and disposal costs. |
Compare at least three order volumes and calculate cost per accepted unit after applying the supplier’s expected defect or rejection rate. |
High |
| 7 |
Check minimum order quantity and inventory exposure. |
MOQ, order frequency, and stock coverage |
Prefer an MOQ that can be consumed within the planned production cycle and does not create excessive obsolete or aged inventory. |
Record standard MOQ, trial MOQ, color or decoration surcharges, pallet quantity, storage requirements, and the supplier’s split-shipment policy. |
Medium |
| 8 |
Assess supply continuity and lead-time reliability. |
Lead time, on-time delivery, and capacity |
Track quoted lead time against actual performance. A useful supplier scorecard should measure on-time-in-full delivery over at least 6 to 12 months. |
Verify production capacity, raw-material availability, backup equipment, tooling ownership, business-continuity plans, and communication during disruptions. |
High |
| 9 |
Review quality systems and regulatory documentation. |
Defect rate, traceability, and compliance |
Agree on measurable acceptance criteria, sampling plans, critical defects, major defects, minor defects, and a corrective-action response time. |
Request batch traceability, certificates of analysis, material declarations, change-control procedures, audit records, and applicable food-contact or cosmetic-packaging documents. |
High |
| 10 |
Use a weighted supplier comparison before making the final decision. |
Sustainability, cost, quality, and reliability score |
Example weighting: sustainability 25%, total cost 25%, product performance 20%, quality 15%, delivery reliability 10%, and service responsiveness 5%. |
Score each supplier from 1 to 5 using the same evidence requirements, then document assumptions, risks, corrective actions, and approval conditions. |
High |